Addition of Antisidetone Circuit to Vintage Telephones



General


On his website, Colin Chambers describes an anti-sidetone network circuit to put in the base of a vintage phone that uses an external ringer box. Having five such phones, I decided to build the circuit and update my old phones. The 600-ohm-center-tapped to 600-ohm-center-tapped transformers were only $2.00 each, or $2.50 each with shipping, for five transformers. But no surprise, each phone was different, so I had to come up with a different wiring diagram for each phone.

Basic Circuit

Layout Requirements:

Small, low profile
Easy to build
Cut spaces between tracks instead of etching
Straight cuts to make cuts easier
Cheap transformer, Mouser 42TL016-RC, specified to take only 100 volts for 1 minute, but it is okay as it only sees line voltage of 48 volts and not ringing voltage

Circuit

The antisidetone circuit can be thought of as a transformer with three windings and a line impedance matching network. When a line signal is present, the antisidetone circuit works by applying the line signal to the transformer primaries connected in series and thus the current through the windings is in-phase producing an additive flux and induces a voltage in the secondary winding. When the signal is from the telephone transmitter, the signal is applied to the junction of the two primaries, and the windings are in parallel. Thus the current through the windings is out-of-phase and cancel so there is no flux and no voltage is induced in the secondary winding. The simplified diagrams below help illustrate the local transmitter signal cancellation and do not show the signal that is produced by the transmitter and sent to the line.



Anti-Sidetone Circuit
Schematic diagram



Signal From Line
Simplified Diagram



Signal From Transmitter
Simplified Diagram



Tested boards

Click on the photos below for construction details and photos.



Stem Board Layout
used on 1910 phone



Board Layout with Connector
used on 1919 candlestick phone



Board Layout with Connector
used on 1919 candlestick phone





Strowger Board Layout
used on 1922 phone



Large Board Layout
used on 1928 phone



Small Board Layout
used on 1930 phone




Phones:


1910 Western Electric 20AL with no dial


1910

Western Electric 20AL

3PPC hook switch
(3-pole Progressive Contact)



1910 Phone With
Anti-Sidetone Circuit
Schematic diagram



Stem Board
mounted in 1910 phone





1919 50AL with Western Electric type five dial.


1919

Western Electric 50AL

Western Electric type 5H dial

3PPC hook switch

Two 1P1T dial off-normal switches

Normally-closed leaf connects
receiver until dialing,
at which time the receiver
connection is opened.

Normally-open leaf
shorts the line during dialing.



1919 Phone With
Anti-Sidetone Circuit
Schematic diagram



Board with Connector
mounted in 1919 phone




1922 Automatic Electric Type 21 Strowger PAX L427A with Automatic Electric type 24 dial


1922
Strowger PAX L427A

Automatic Electric type 24 dial

1P2T hook switch

1P1T dial off-normal switch

Dial 1P1T off-normal switch
leaves are open until dialing.



1922 Strowger PAX L427A Phone With
AE Type 24 Dial
Anti-Sidetone Circuit
Schematic diagram



Strowger Board
mounted in 1922 phone





1928 B1 base mount with Automatic Electric type 51A dial that has an AK-26 Western Electric switch stack (will work with Western Electric type 2 dial)


1928
Western Electric B1 base mount

Automatic Electric type 51A dial
with AK-26 AE switch
stack or
Western Electric type 2 dial

2P2T hook switch

1P2T dial off-normal switch

Dial 1P2T off-normal switch
center leaf connects
receiver until dial center leaf
switches during dialing to
short the line, at which time
the receiver connection is
opened.




1928 B1 Phone
With WE Type 2 Dial
Anti-Sidetone Circuit
Schematic diagram



Large Board
mounted in 1928 phone





1928 B1 base mount with Automatic Electric type 51A dial that has an AK-25 AE standard switch stack
1930 D1 base mount with Automatic Electric type 51A dial that has an AK-25 AE standard switch stack


1928
Western Electric B1 base mount

1930
Western Electric D1 base mount

Automatic Electric type 51A dial
with AK-25 AE standard switch
stack

2P2T hook switch

3PPC dial off-normal switch

Dial 3PPC off-normal switch
leaves are open until dialing.

The first two leaves short
the receiver before the third
leaf connects to short line.



1928 B1 or 1930 D1 Phone With
AE Type 51A Dial
Anti-Sidetone Circuit
Schematic diagram



Large Board
mounted in 1928 phone





Small Board
mounted in 1930 phone





Performance

Mixed. All phones sounded better than the 600-ohm-to-900-ohm autotransformer I was using before. The 1910 had the least sidetone reduction, the 1930 the best. The 1919 was hardest for the called person to hear, the 1910 was easiest. There is a lot of variance in the transmitters and receivers used in these phones, so I an not surprised by the variance in sidetone reduction.

All of the phones worked well with modern phones also on the line, so it seems the addition of this circuit keeps the old phones from loading down the line.


Copyright Dale Thompson,
November 10, 2014 through
last revision on November 26, 2014